Digital MarketingLearnWhy Your Website Isn’t Ranking – And It’s Not Your Keywords

Why Your Website Isn’t Ranking – And It’s Not Your Keywords

Last Updated May 08, 2025.

You’ve done your keyword research. You’ve picked the right terms. But your site still isn’t showing up where you want it to. The problem? It’s probably not your keywords. It’s everything around them. If you’re a business owner or marketer wondering why your site isn’t climbing, this article will help you get to the bottom of it.

Have a question? Contact Us

Google Doesn’t Just Look at Keywords – It Looks at the Whole Picture

Search engines have changed. Matching keywords isn’t enough anymore. Google is trying to understand the quality and reliability of your site.

It’s not just about what you’re saying – it’s how well your site works, how it’s structured, and how real users respond to it.

1. If Your Website’s Hard to Use, It Won’t Rank Well

The issue: Your content might have keywords, but your site layout is unclear.

Why it matters: A confusing site makes it harder for both users and Google to understand what’s important.

What to do:

  1. Organise your content around topics – not just keywords.
  2. Use internal links to guide people logically through your pages.
  3. Make sure each service or offering has its own page. Avoid lumping everything together.

2. Content Isn’t Just About Having Something on the Page

The issue: Your content might be technically “fine,” but it doesn’t help users much.

Why it matters: Google is trying to answer questions. If your content doesn’t do that, it won’t make the cut.

What to do:

  1. Write with real people in mind, not algorithms.
  2. Go beyond listing services – explain how you help, show what makes you different, and be specific.
  3. Make sure the content on each page lines up with what someone actually wants when they search that topic.

3. A Slow, Frustrating Site Will Work Against You

The issue: Your site is slow, unresponsive, or clunky on mobile.

Why it matters: Users leave fast – and Google notices.

What to do:

  1. Compress your images and ditch any bloated code.
  2. Make sure your site works properly on phones and tablets.
  3. Use tools like GTmetrix or PageSpeed Insights to spot performance issues and fix them properly.

4. Technical SEO Problems Are Easy to Miss – But Hard to Ignore

The issue: Your site might look fine on the surface, but search engines can’t crawl or index it properly.

Common culprits can include broken internal links, duplicate or missing meta data, too many low-value pages, incorrect use of canonical tags.

Why it matters: If Google can’t read your site, it won’t rank your site.

What to do:

  1. Get a proper technical audit done – not just a quick scan with a free tool.
  2. Remove or block pages that don’t add value.
  3. Keep your sitemap clean and your robots.txt file up to date.

5. You Have Backlinks – But Are They Quality Assets?

Problem: Your link profile includes purchased backlinks or links from websites that have no connection to your industry.

Why it matters: These kinds of links usually provide no SEO benefit and, if part of a wider manipulative pattern, can contribute to ranking issues. Google’s systems, including SpamBrain, are designed to detect and ignore or devalue low-quality links – and in some cases, they may trigger penalties.

What to do:

  • Focus on earning links from credible websites within your niche or industry.
  • Use sustainable strategies like digital PR, useful content, or collaborative partnerships that result in natural links.
  • Only disavow links if you’ve had a manual action or have strong reason to believe spammy links are affecting performance.

6. Google Watches What Users Do – Not Just What You Write

The issue: People aren’t sticking around on your site.

Why it matters: High bounce rates and low engagement tell Google your site might not be helpful.

What to do:

  1. Improve how your site looks and feels.
  2. Make it easy for users to understand what you do and what to do next.
  3. Add trust signals – like reviews, guarantees, and real contact info.

People Also Ask

Why does my site not rank even with the right keywords?
Because Google looks at usability, technical health, trust, and engagement – not just keyword use.

How can I check if technical issues are affecting my site?
Use tools like Screaming Frog, Sitebulb, or Google Search Console to uncover crawl and indexation problems.

Do backlinks still matter for SEO?
Yes, but quality beats quantity. Links from unrelated or spammy sites can hurt your rankings.

Does user behaviour affect my Google ranking?
Yes. If users bounce quickly or don’t engage, Google may assume your site isn’t a good result.

Quick Table: If Your Keywords Aren’t the Problem, What Might Be?

What’s WrongWhat You Can Do
Poor structure or navigationGroup content logically, use clear links
Unhelpful or vague contentBe specific, answer real questions
Slow or broken experienceImprove performance and mobile usability
Technical SEO issuesGet a proper audit, fix crawl problems
Bad backlinksBuild genuine links, clean up bad ones if you receive manual action
Low engagementBetter UX, clearer content, more trust

Take Action

Ranking isn’t just about keywords anymore. It’s about the full experience your site offers – to both users and search engines.

When you fix the things around the keywords, that’s when rankings start to move.

Written by Ash at Outfox SEO
Last updated: 1 April 2025

Book a Free SEO Consultation →